Blog header image for Growth before cost, and why the revenue case goes missing after the deal

Growth before cost, and why the revenue case goes missing after the deal

Reading Time: 4 minutes

In M&A, an acquirer buys top-line revenue as much as bottom-line profit when deciding whether to make an offer.

In diligence, the revenue case gets more scrutiny than almost anything else, because it is what justifies the price. Yet after completion it fades into the background, and the integration plan fills up with systems, headcount and property.

That matters more than it used to. Hold periods are stretching beyond the three-year cycle many funds planned around; capital is costlier, and financial engineering and cost-out no longer carry the return on their own. The latest analysis from Gain on mid-market Private Equity returns shows revenue growth driving almost 90 per cent of value creation.

We believe the revenue case should be run with the same discipline after completion as the cost case, with a named owner, a mechanism and a plan that starts before the deal is announced. In practice that means three things: commercial leadership in diligence, protecting revenue before you cut, and treating cross-sell as a mechanism with an owner rather than an assumed percentage.

We tested that view with senior commercial, marketing, finance and M&A leaders from our network, people who have run integrations, advised on deals and sat on the boards of PE- and VC-backed businesses. Around a table with decades of combined deal experience, nobody could name a listed company or private equity house that is consistently good at post-deal growth.

 

Bring commercial leadership in before announcement 

“The danger zone is pre-announce,” one commercial leader told us. “Once you’ve announced, you’re in market, whether you like it or not.” Revenue growth that is not designed before the deal rarely materialises after it. Growth also takes time to build, so every month spent waiting for integration to finish is a month you do not get back.

What we see instead is commercial leaders arriving after the announcement to inherit spend nobody budgeted for, value drivers that cannot be executed and KPIs they had no hand in shaping. Commercial due diligence, where it exists, is too often a broad market review by a non-specialist: “A hundred pages long, full of charts, and zero actions.” Investment theses list technology and headcount synergies, with no section on revenue synergies at all.

Part of the reason is who sits at the top table. Many PE-backed small- to mid-cap businesses have a CEO, a CFO and a Chief People Officer, but no commercial leader at C-suite level. A year after the deal, organic growth stalls and the call goes out for an urgent interim. Often the need was permanent all along and only addressed once it became urgent. “Interim doesn’t even always mean interim in this function.”

We would change three things. Bring a seasoned commercial leader in from diligence through announcement to integration, even for a couple of days a week over a few months. Formalise commercial due diligence so that it ends in a list of actions with owners. Write must-have commercial KPIs into the investment thesis so the board commits to the commercial agenda from day one.

 

Protect revenue before you cut 

Cost goes first for good reasons: within a fixed hold, it is the fastest and most proven lever. The hidden assumption is that existing revenue will hold steady while everything around it is reorganised. Often it does not.

The phrase “one plus one equals three” drew groans in the room. One leader offered more honest maths: without deliberate effort, “normally, one plus one is one and a half.” Products fall out of alignment, prices drift out of sync, and sales teams from sister businesses end up chasing the same customers.

Systems consolidation is where this hurts the most. Two CRMs become one, a duplicate platform is switched off, and nobody considers what that does to revenue. One business did exactly that, and the demand-generation platform switched off in the tidy-up was the one generating the revenue. In a business that lives on inbound leads, that revenue line can fall close to zero.
Before anything is cut, someone needs to own a simple question: what is each system, team and product line doing for revenue today? You need a revenue strategy just to protect what you already have

 

Build cross-sell as a mechanism 

“Ten per cent extra revenue from cross-sell” is one of the most common deal assumptions, and one with very little behind it. Every cross-sell relies on one of three mechanisms: hand the customer to a specialist, make an introduction, or sell something new. Most teams do not know which one they have signed up to.

Incentives often dictate what actually happens. Introducing a sister business to a strong account puts your own margin and reputation at risk if they drop the ball. Without a clear reason and a reward, salespeople will not engage with the plan.

One group ran a weekly all-hands cross-sell call. It achieved very little, because nobody on it had a cross-sell target or understood what the acquired business sold. It only gained traction when the call was replaced by a smaller, trained team focused on the largest customers, with KPIs they were accountable for.

That is the shift we would make: decide which mechanism you are using, give it an owner and reward the behaviour you want.

 

Signs your integration is looking inwards 

Before completion

  • The investment thesis lists technology and headcount synergies, but no revenue synergies.
  • Cross-sell appears as a percentage uplift, with no mechanism, owner or incentive behind it.
  • No senior commercial leader is involved before announcement.

In the first 100 days

  • The integration plan covers systems, headcount and property, but no revenue line has an owner.
  • Systems are consolidated without anyone modelling the effect on revenue.

Six to twelve months in

  • Sales teams across brands chase the same accounts, and prices drift out of sync.
  • Discounting becomes the way to hit the monthly number.
  • Anticipated organic growth does not materialise, and customer retention falters.
  • Customers are no longer clear on what the new group stands for, and why they should buy.
  • An urgent request goes out for an interim commercial leader.

 

If you are planning a deal, in the middle of an integration, or wondering why growth has stalled since the last one, we would be glad to talk.